Originally Posted by
supremester
My goodness what an active thread! I think The Temptations dodged a bullet with Dennis Edwards: the man who did the impossible: replacing David Ruffin. Jean Terrell, talented as she is, Supremely so in fact, wasn't able to fill Diana Ross' shoes. I do not believe at all the theory about Motown killing JMC as too much occurred to refute that. I DO believe many Supremes fans, just like me, lost interest. I just talked to a woman on the plane my age who "liked" the DR&TS hits, "LOVED" Up The Ladder - but no other JMC cuts. She likes Ross solo best except DoobeDoodnDoobe [["it gives me a back ache") Each time a new Supreme popped up, it was another strange face. I don't even think anyone but a few were even comparing the two acts anymore. JMC had their hits, Miss Ross had Ain't No Mountain and it was over. The Supremes got boing trying to emulate DR&TS years too late and new groups made them look silly. Some of their TV appearances are humiliating to even watch. I don't think Lady Sings The Blues had any effect on JMC cuz by then, it was all over but the shouting. They were playing to half empty rooms in Vegas - bad sign. I love The Flos - and am friendly with Lynda, Scherrie and Joyce but I do not approve of them issuing CDs of DR&TS/JMC hits under the name The Supremes. The Scherrie years is fine by me, however. The interesting thing about Mary vs FLOS is that with The FLOS you got 3 real Motown signed Supremes - including 3 lead singers while with Mary, you got a bg singer taking over the lead. The FLOS were doing a real Supremes show while Mary was doing her solo show with Supremes songs. I don't know what the issue was. I saw Mary live in the 80's and no way was it a Supremes act. I applaud Mary's artistic vision to sing lead in her own show, but don't accept that as "preserving the legacy" or any such silliness. Also, I think it's mean spirited of Mary to fight former lead singers of The Supremes for singing their hits. Also, I applaud Motown for not allowing Mary to perform as The Supremes with her doing the leads in front of two unknowns - that is counter-productive to the legacy. In a perfect world, they'd all be BFFs and out doing their thing together.
Bookmarks