Eddie or Melvin

[honest man]

Hello lovely people been playing my Motown lists today and thought i'd ask the question which version do you prefer, mine is Eddies's but you may think different.cheers.
https://youtu.be/cG5OVKmNXk8 https://youtu.be/YUYbGjxwjlc

[jsmith]

Eddie everytime.

[arr&bee]

While both are good,melvin's gets the nod here.

[Motown Eddie]

I prefer Melvin Franklin on The Tempts' "I Truly, Truly Believe".

[McMotown]

Love both of them, but today I'm prefering Melvin's version.

[lockhartgary]

I prefer Melvin's version.

[marv2]

I love Eddie's voice, but I prefer Melvin Franklin's version of this song:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cG5OVKmNXk8

[TomatoTom123]

Really just love both, in equal amounts... but Melvin's was on the Wish It Would Rain album so is in stereo... and I love a bit of stereo :)

[Encyclopedia Mack]

On this particular track, Melvin. Eddie's natural tenor doesn't seem to mesh well with this particular track for me.