Yeah PianoMD...it really comes down to the criteria. There is certainly room for disagreement, even based on the criteria since this is not. an exact science...additions, deletions, and placement, but some folks ignore the criteria and disagree based on personal preference. Personal preference is a different list. I often have this discussion on bass players where my personal favorites my differ (somewhat) to whom I believe are the "greatest" based on solid criteria.
Originally Posted by PianoMD